Internal Proposal Topic Memo
Once again, this topic memo is written
in preparation for the next assignment, this time an internal proposal; in this memo you are simply to get the instructor's
permission to go ahead with the topic you have selected for your
proposal. In order to get this permission, you need to describe fully to me
the topic you are going to write about.
Problems
The internal proposal is a memo that you as a member of an organization (of any
type) write to a superior proposing a solution to a problem. First, then, you
need to examine the various organizations in which you are involved and think of
what is wrong with them or what could be done better. You may also choose an
organization you used to be a member of that had some problems. You may
act as if you still are a part of the organization and as if the problem is
current even though the situation has passed.
A "problem" need not be a disastrous situation; any area
of the organization that could be improved can be regarded as a problem
area. But not just any problem will do. The problem must not be too
large--so large that only the highest officers in the organization would
be qualified to address it. Also, the problem cannot be too small--so
small that a proposal of just a few lines would suffice. (The internal
proposal must be at least a two-page memo.) For example, if you want an
organization to invest hundreds of thousands of dollars to upgrade its
computer systems, then a two-page memo will not do the trick. When you
want to initiate major capital expenditures, you first ask superiors to
study a problem before proposing anything. On the other hand,
if a solution is obvious and inexpensive--like a new coffee maker to
replace the old one that just quit--then a two-page memo is overkill.
Causes of Problems
Once you have identified a
problem, consider as well the causes of the problem, since it is
the causes that your solution should eliminate. For example, if
dwindling attendance at chapter meetings is the problem, various causes
could be to blame--morale, communication, conflicts with other events,
and so on. The cause of the problem should determine the solution you
propose. If you cannot remedy the causes of a problem, then you have
no proposal to make.
Examples
Possible problems and solutions are many; most do not involve
large expenditures. Here are just a very few examples:
- in order to eliminate a problem with intercom etiquette, an employee
proposed that a seminar be held instructing all employees in how to use
the new intercom system and that a list of guidelines be created;
- in order to provide battered women with the opportunity to store
some of their belongings during their stay at a women's shelter, an
employee proposed that a storage shed be constructed in the back yard of
the shelter;
- in order to eliminate confusion and hard feelings concerning
holidays, personal days, and sick days at a company, an employee
proposed that the company's policy be published and distributed to all
employees;
- in order to eliminate potentially dangerous situations in a mining
company, an employee proposed that all employees be required to attain a
basic level of literacy.
Most of the best internal proposals identify procedures that could be
changed with little or no expense in order to make an organization run
more efficiently.
Solutions
All proposals must describe a
specific, concrete, and tangible method of solving the problem
you identify. If, for example, your organization suffers from poor
morale, you must propose something more than the idea that employees need
to exhibit a happier, perkier attitude. Instead, you must propose a
program or policy or change of methods that will result in a better
attitude. In addition, most proposals need to be at least
minimally researched: the
cost of products sometimes needs to be determined, for example, or
certain statistics showing that your problem exists might need to be
gathered and presented.
Here is an overview of the proposal topic memo in terms of SCAMP:
- Style: The purpose of this
memo is to get
the instructor's permission to go ahead with your idea for the proposal,
so you want to impress your audience that you know what you are doing and
can do a good job on the assignment. In other words, be fairly
formal and direct.
- Chunking: Remember to start the message with the four
audience-centered elements of a good business writing introduction: purpose,
context, good will, and overview of what is to come. Break down the message into
chunks with heads that correspond to the main parts of your message. I
would expect sections like this: Organization, Position, Problem, Cause,
Solution, and Superior, Cost, Research.
Memos are headed with the standard TO, FROM, DATE, and SUBJECT; check the pages
in Kolin for memo format.
- Audience: Your
audience is the instructor; when you write
the proposal, your audience will be your superior in an
organization.
For now, however, your audience is someone who probably does not know
anything about your organization, your position in the organization, the
problem you see, the solution that might fix the problem, etc. So be
sure to keep the information needs of your audience in mind: describe the
subject fully to me. The
audience is also wanting to be persuaded that you will do a good job with
this topic.
- Message: Describe in different sections the various parts of
your proposal topic. Here are the subjects you want to cover:
- the
organization in which you are involved or were involved;
- your
position in the organization;
-
the problem you have identified for
which
you think you have a solution;
- the specific, concrete, tangible
solution
to the problem you have identified;
- the audience for the proposal,
that
is, your superior in the organization;
- any ancillary topics that might
occur to the instructor, such as cost and the time you think it might
take to implement the proposal.
- research you will have to do in order to make the proposal.
- Purpose: Your purpose is to obtain permission to proceed with
your internal proposal topic.